graphite vs composite pickleball paddles

Graphite vs Composite Pickleball Paddles – A Helpful Guide For Beginners

Graphite vs composite pickleball paddles.  The debate as to which type of paddle is the best has gone on for years now.  And it's only getting stronger as more pickleball paddles come out using either graphite or composite surface materials.

So which one is the best?  What are the differences?  This is a question I get asked all the time.  So, I created this helpful guide to provide a real, honest answer.

So what is the difference between graphite vs composite pickleball paddles? I'll cover that more in-depth below but the short answer is this - weight and texture. Graphite paddles provide the lightest paddles surface in the game today while Composite paddles are slightly heavier but provide the best textured surface ideal for spin.

My Favorites

#1

Best Graphite Paddle

- The Paddletek Tempest Wave II -

The best graphite paddle for those just starting out.  It comes in a "Pro" version for those looking to up their game but the original Tempest Wave is a fantastic lightweight graphite paddle for those still learning the nuances of the game.  It's the paddle I recommend to all beginners.

4.5 of 5 stars

#2

Best Graphite Paddle Runner-Up      - Onix Z5 Graphite Paddle - 

The Z5 from Onix has become a legend in the pickleball arena because it was one of the first graphite paddles to hit the market and has since stood the test of time.  It is Onix's trademark paddle is a great option for those heading to the court for some friendly competition.

4 of 5 stars

#1

Best Composite Paddle                              - The Prince Response Pro -

I've been playing with the Response Pro from Prince for years now and it hasn't disappointed me once.  It's extremely accurate and has arguably the largest sweet spot I've ever seen! Well worth its more expensive price tag.  And it's endorsed by Simone Jardim - 3 time gold medal champion!

4.5 of 5 stars


In recent years, pickleball has become a wildly popular, world-famous game. It’s similar to tennis in terms of the equipment you need to play: a court, net, pickleball, and of course, pickleball paddles. There are a lot of pickleball paddles available on the market, but it can be difficult to know where to begin. 

I'm going to take a look at the differences between a graphite and composite pickle paddle, as well as our top picks for both, so you can make an informed decision on which is right for you.

Composite vs Graphite Pickleball Paddles

Here are the main differences between graphite and composite pickleball paddles.

Cost

Let’s be honest, one of the first things that come to mind when we think of making any purchase is how much it costs. When it comes to graphite and composite pickleball paddles, there isn’t much difference in price. 

The composite pickleball paddle is technically the cheaper of the two with one at the low end of the range costing roughly $45. A low-end graphite paddle, though, only costs about $60. Neither one is going to cost you more than $145 even at the top end of the range. 

Technically, the cost is a very small factor in your decision-making process. That said, if you’re just looking for something cheap to get you going, I have a small list of good composite paddles all in the $50 range.  Click here for that.

Now wooden paddles will come in well below the $50 price range.  However, keep in mind that wooden paddles don’t give you the same pickleball experience that you could be having with graphite or a composite paddle.  I never recommend them.

Material

So, what’s even the difference between the two in terms of material?  And most importantly, what are composite and graphite?

Composite

graphite vs composite pickleball paddles

A composite pickleball paddle is made using a variety of materials. They are
"composed" of a hybrid of materials instead of one single material (like graphite).

This mesh and molding approach to combine materials allows composite materials to have a textured surface and can come with any type of paddle core in the middle.  

Cores like Polymer, Nomex and Aluminum are most common but polymer cores (in both composite and graphite paddles) are BY FAR the most common because of the response they give players. 

The combination of these materials creates a comfortable, foam-like body that is not only easier on the hands, but smoother, softer, quieter and very responsive.

For more helpful info on paddle types and materials check this article out.

In my humble opinion, I prefer composite paddles because of the additional power they provide.  They have great "ball grab" ability for putting spin on the ball.  Plus, I've never felt another paddle respond like the Response Pro (no pun intended) - which also happens to be an elite composite paddle. 

Graphite

graphite vs composite pickleball paddles

Graphite paddles generally use the same paddle cores as composite paddles (Polymer, Nomex or Aluminum) but their claim to fame centers around their airy lightweight feel.

Weight

Graphite paddles tend to be lighter than composite paddles.  Sometimes by a full ounce or more.  

However, generally speaking graphite paddles are going to average around 7.5oz while composite are in the 8.0 ounce range.

But can you actually feel the difference?  Yes, many players claim they can feel the lightweight comfort that only graphite paddle can give them.  

Aside from the weight of the racquet, many players are attracted to graphite pickleball paddles because when combined with a good honeycomb polymer core, the paddle with give you elite levels of touch and feel.

I've felt this with the Tempest Wave and the more expensive Tempest Pro.  The racquet almost feels like an extension of your hand,  Helping you achieve better accuracy.  Where your hand goes, the balls.  

Durability

While graphite is generally said to be more durable in terms of face finish, you need to think about both the paddle surface and the core when it comes to which materials are going to last.

Whether or not you choose to go with a paddle face of graphite, composite, plastic, or wood, make sure you choose a face that includes ultraviolet inhibitors to minimize sun damage as well as discoloration. 

This gives you the best chance of preserving whichever paddle face you’ve chosen. The key when you’re buying anything, really, is making sure you’re getting value for your money.

Graphite vs Composite Pickleball Paddles - Pros And Cons For Composite

On the pro side, the composite pickleball paddle has more oomph and plow through behind.  This is perfect if you're a power player like am. 

Composite paddles are made for power players who like to add spin to their passing shots and rip their serves. 

If you tend to take the initiative during a match and dicate the pace of the action. with aggressive shots, you may find yourself gravitating towards a composite pickleball paddle versus a graphite one.  

Composite paddles also come in various shapes like "wide body" or "blade" shapes which help meet the requirements of players looking for different things at different skill levels. The textured surface also makes it easier to put good spin on the ball. 

Personally I get the most accurate, baseline to baseline power from high-level composite paddles like the Response Pro from Prince.  Not that graphite paddles cannot deliver that, I just find that composite paddles deliver this effortlessly.

The main drawback to composite paddles tends to be their level of touch at the net.  Getting consistent, soft, accurate dinks at the kitchen line may prove slightly harder with a composite paddle...especially a cheap one.  

If you like to dink your opponents to death and lull them to sleep with safe, soft shots that always land in bounds, composite paddles may not give you what your're looking for. 

Graphite vs Composite Pickleball Paddles - Pros And Cons For Graphite

Many professional pickleball players prefer a graphite paddle for a variety of reasons. Although the graphite portion of the paddle is light and rigid, the paddle itself provides exceptional levels of touch and feel.

It really is amazing that even though graphite, as a surface, is more rigid than composite, it actually provides a softer touch.

If you're a player who likes to win at the kitchen line, and always aim for well placed third shot drops, then I'd steer you towards a top of the line graphite paddle.  

Response and feel at the net is something graphite paddles excel at and that's where its a ton of fun to play with them!

In terms of cons for graphite paddles, their strength can also be their weakness.  By that I mean, that lightweight air feel limits these paddles from providing enough power. 

I find that composite paddles give me more consistent deep serves and return of serves.  Plow through and game winning passing shots can be slightly harder with lighter graphite paddles.

On top of that, it's also worth noting that there are A TON of graphites paddles on the market for any new player to choose from.  This is also a disadvantage because it can very easy to get sucked into a paddle that looks good, touts a high grade graphite paddle face but in the end, isn't a good paddle.  

It's easy to make a cheap USAPA approved graphite paddle; so buyer beware. Stick to brands like Pro-Lite, Paddletek, Selkirk, Engage, Onix and Prince versus lesser known brands that only sell on Amazon.

Which One Has Better Grip?

When it comes to grip, size is an important factor for making a killer shot. You don’t want a grip that is too big or too small.

One that is too big can cause a player to miss a fantastic shot, while a small grip can be just as uncomfortable, although it does not present the same challenges.

When it comes to graphite versus composite pickleball paddle, though, which grip is better?

The answer is actually neither – both come with the option of small and large-sized grips. It’s worth noting that it’s usually better to use a small-size grip, but that obviously depends on the player. 

Pickleball grips are generally only available in large and small, but it’s possible to add an overgrip if needed to make it slightly bigger.

My Top Picks

Whether you’re opting to go for graphite or composite pickleball paddle, here are my top picks!

Best Graphite Paddle -
The Paddletek Tempest Wave II

I've played with a lot graphite paddles over the years and none of them are as consistent as the the Tempest Wave II from Paddletek.  It's lightweight, predictable and always on point.  In fact, some tournament level players characterize the Tempest Wave II as the one oaddle that feels like an extension of their hand.  

Paddletek Tempest Wave II Specifications

  • Weight: 7.4 to 7.8 ounces
  • Face Style: Traditional
  • Face Finish: Graphite
  • Paddle Length: 15 7/8”
  • Paddle Width: 5 1/4”
  • Core Material: Honeycomb Polymer

Pros

  • Great touch at the net for dinking
  • Very lightweight and easy on the arms
  • Polymer core delivers good pop for put-aways and excellent touch
  • Extremely versatile for any skill range
  • Really good paddle for beginners learning the game
  • Great paddle for learning the third-shot drop 

Cons

  • May not provide enough power for bangers and lacks a little baseline to baseline pop

There are very few graphite paddles on the market better than Onix Z5. This graphite pickleball paddle is one of the most affordable high-quality rackets out there. The Onix Z5 has a larger than average sweet spot too, which benefits players of all skill levels.

Onix Z5 Graphite Pickleball Paddle Specifications:

  • Weight: 7.5 to 8.1 ounces
  • Face Style: Widebody
  • Face Finish: Graphite
  • Paddle Length: 15 1/2”
  • Paddle Width: 8 1/8”
  • Core Material: Honeycomb Nomex core

Pros

  • The widebody design has a wide hitting surface, which means a larger sweet spot for greater strength and spin
  • At an average weight of 7.8 ounces, it’s heavy enough to give a significant amount of power, while shots still feel light and effortless
  • Graphite exterior allows the paddle to be durable and long-lasting
  • Versatile for any skill range
  • Upgraded contour Gamma grip with 4 ¼-inch grip size
  • Powerful tool that still does not fall under the category of a “heavy paddle”

Cons

  • None

I currently play with the Prince Response Pro firmly believe it's the best composite paddle I've ever played with.  In fact, it's arguably the most well rounded paddle on the market today.  What I love most about the Response Pro is how large the sweet spot on the paddle face feels.  I've experienced first had how hitting the ball, even off center, results and remarkebly accurate shot.  You simply won't get this with composite paddles.  From beginner to expert, I highly recommend this paddle to anyone! 

Prince Response Pro Paddle Specifications

  • Weight: 7.8 to 8.3 ounces
  • Face Style: Widebody
  • Face Finish: Composite
  • Paddle Length: 15 3/4”
  • Paddle Width: 8 1/4”
  • Core Material: Polymer honeycomb core

Pros

  • Arguably the largest sweet spot on the market today making it very forgiving
  •  Awesome paddle for game winning passing shots
  • Composite exterior with texture, great for adding top spin and backspin
  • Great paddle for beginners or tournament level players
  • Large paddle face with Prince's trademark oval shape for large hitting area

Cons

  • Definitely a high price point paddle

Other Great Graphite and Composite Pickleball Options

Selkirk is a well-known, high-quality brand when it comes to pickleball paddles, and the Selkirk Prime S2 lives up to the name. Similar to the Onix Z5, this paddle has a large sweet spot, making it easier for all skill levels to complete powerful shots. It may have the Onix Z5 beat when it comes to weight distribution throughout the handle, as it's one of the most well-balanced paddles on the market.

Selkirk Prime S2 Graphite Pickleball Paddle Specifications:

  • Weight: 7.4 to 7.8 ounces
  • Face Finish: Fiberglass FiberFlex
  • FacePaddle Length: 15 3/4"
  • Paddle Width: 8.0"
  • Core Material: Polypropylene polymer core

Pros

  • Polymer core allows great cushioning and a balanced grip
  • The large surface area of the paddle gives beginners and advanced players the ability to easily find their sweet spot
  • Light and easy to use
  • Superior shot control
  • It’s lightweight and versatile, which makes it super easy to control
  • Graphite build increases its lasting power
  • One of the best valued paddles on the market when it comes to quality
  • Great for beginner to advanced players

Cons

  • Because this paddle is so light, it is not built for power hits

This composite pickleball paddle was made with experienced players in mind, so it’s not ideal for rookie pickleball players. If you’re just getting your feet wet, we recommend avoiding this paddle, as it could put you off of the game. If you’re a veteran player, though, the Paddletek Bantam EX-L can seriously work to your advantage.

Paddletek Bantam EX-L Pickleball Paddle Specifications:

  • Weight: 7.8 to 8.4 ounces
  • Core Material: High-grade polymer
  • Paddle Face: composite 
  • Paddle Length: 15 5/8”
  • Paddle Width: 7 ¾”

Pros

  • The combination of the large paddle width and the slightly heftier weight of this paddle makes it one of the best shock absorbing paddles available.
  • The benefits of the composite honeycomb core add a boost of shot power
  • The velvet-textured surface adds an extra spin to your shot
  • Medium-weight for a powerful paddle
  • Provides great vibration absorption with its even distribution of weight
  • Cushioned surface for a quieter experience
  • Offers power without the muscle strain

Cons

  • Difficult to achieve required accuracy with the amount of power behind this paddle
  • Not ideal for amateur players

Graphite vs Composite Pickleball Paddles - Conclusion

Now that you know the essentials about graphite and composite pickleball paddles, hopefully you’re closer to figuring out which one is right for you.

When it comes down to it, whether it’s graphite or composite is not the most important factor in picking out your paddle. Each has its benefits and drawbacks, and their differences are only slight. 

The bottom line? Buy the paddle that "feels" the best in your hands. While you may already have a specific brand or model in mind, it all comes down to what feels right for your skill level.

If you’re comfortable with your paddle, the game is going to be that much more enjoyable. 

Pickleball is quickly gaining in popularity and is a fun activity to pass the time or even grow to play professionally.  Take your time and ask questions when picking out your paddle to be sure you get it right!

About Me

I’m just a lover of all sports that involve a racquet, net and a ball.  My whole family loves and plays pickleball regularly. I started this website to help give people like you the performance tips and buying info they need to make an educated and informed purchase. 

The products I recommend here have been researched, analyzed, compared and in a lot of cases bought, worn and used.  If it’s a bad product, I don’t recommend it. Any small purchase made from this site gives me a small commission that helps fund the growth of the site to provide you more helpful information.

Leave a Comment: